2024 Canadian Poncho Calendars are Now Available! CLICK HERE

 

 

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Factory Shifter and Linkage vs Hurst, Pros and Cons


Addicted!

Status: Offline
Posts: 339
Date:
Factory Shifter and Linkage vs Hurst, Pros and Cons


Thought I would put this out to the masses here in CP Land. As some of you know I have been collecting parts and pieces to convert my semi survivor 1966 Beaumont from PG on the column to 4 speed with the bench seat. I have most of the small parts and it is time to pick up the big ticket items; shifter and transmission. As the car is mostly stock I wanted to go with a stock shifter, however these are old parts and I am concerned that after chasing down the correct parts it is still going to need a rebuild to shift properly. There are companies that offer rebuilt units, but these are the price of a good Muncie trans!

I see reconditioned vintage Hurst shifters complete for the price of a un-restored GM shifter and have considered one of these too. Most of the cars I have owned have been equipped with Hurst Shifters and I have been happy with these.

Is the look of a original shifter worth the expense and how is the quality of shifting? What is usually required to recondition an original shifter, do they get much wear or do they just require cleaning up and adjustment along with a re-chroming of the stick?

Looking for your opinions and experiences!

Thanks

 

 



__________________


A Poncho Legend!

Status: Offline
Posts: 48633
Date:

I love those old original shifters but I can guarantee that most of the replies you get will be in favour of a Hurst...

__________________

1966 Strato Chief 2 door, 427 4 speed, 45,000 original miles 

1966 Grande Parisienne, 396 1 of 23 factory air cars



Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 2656
Date:

Yes Carl you are correct. Islander I have the bench seat original style (repop) Muncie Shifter in my Chevelle, it works ok but is very sloppy and noisy. After reading up on the "new" Chinese Hurst shifters it was recommended to try and buy a "vintage" rebuilt one. I found one with a business called Manchester Muncies,the handle was rechromed & the mechanism completely rebuilt, shipped to me $310 U.S. I bought the correct install kit where I work for $210. I will install over the winter and should tighten things up. (I did like the vintage look with the original shifter though!)

__________________


Uber Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3830
Date:

The original shifters in all my old Corvettes rattled and locked up once in awhile. One time leaving me stuck in 4th gear in Montreal heading back home to Kitchener. Clutch was a bit smelly but I got it home and had it changed to a Hurst linkage & shifter.
Same for a few of my Mopars. The original Inland shifters were as junky feeling as the Muncies.
If you're stuck on original look I think you can get a Hurst linkage and adapter to the Muncie style shifter.

__________________

Drifting offshore is a fine way to spend a day!!



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 613
Date:

I have always preferred the look of the Hurst Comp Plus gray cast "T" handle over the original white Muncie ball.
- some period correct items, done in good taste...the Hurst handle just feels right, when laying down rubber
When I bought my '67 SD, I was glad it came with the Hurst shifter instead, while it did need a new bushing kit due to much wear.
- I have never looked for a factory correct one

Islander - got any pictures of you semi survivor 1966 Beaumont Custom...love to see it.


 



-- Edited by Beaumont67SD on Wednesday 24th of December 2014 07:41:12 AM

__________________
owned ten 1967 Beaumonts, over 3 decades


Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 7176
Date:

Comp + shifter all the way.. With the Muncie handle if you I want to look era correct. You'll possibly have to do some fabbing, to attach,  but that is all under the boot....

inland or Muncie shifter. Are just a little sloppy compared to the hurst.

if you buy used linkages, but the hurst pit pack with all new bushings and clips.. Tightens things up real nice.

 

i have a super comp hurst and handle in the 65 lemans..very positive shifting..I re bushed the linkages.

 

do you have a pic of what the original Muncie handle for 66 looks like?



__________________

later...rog

AADD supporting member !!
I'm a collector...not a builder!!Located in sunny central Saskatchewan at the lakehead!


Uber Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3463
Date:

get yourself a pre chinese hurst, you can find a bracket to adapt the muncie handle

muncie shifter is comparable to the 3 in the tree shifter.



__________________

 








Uber Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3932
Date:

They do sell a Muncie replica handle to fit a hurst shifter and they also sell an adapter to fit a Muncie to hurst shifter.



__________________


A Poncho Legend!

Status: Offline
Posts: 35601
Date:

I put a Hurst in my 66 Corvette, and my 69 Z28, and my 72 Ventura, and my 75 Corvette, and liked them    

Short precise shifts    

I now have a 66 B-Body now with a original Munice shifter  I find it strange to say I like it  biggrin  

I think original shifters are like  Quadrajets carbs    they are really great or really bad

 

I'd vote for a Hurst   they are expensive     try for a good used one   

 



__________________

 



Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 7418
Date:

I know when 67rag396 was still with us, he had a stock Muncie shifter in his 67 396 2+2, but it was very sloppy.  He went with a rebuilt Hurst Competition Plus shifter in about 2007 and was much happier.  I am putting a 70 M20 behind a 70 LS6 454, and while I had initially wanted to go with Muncie shifter, I too have decided to go with a rebuilt Competion Plus.  Not sure about your application, but my Muncie shifter bolted to the crossmember, not the transmission which didn't help the situation.



__________________
70 2+2 convertible
70 2+2 hardtop
70 Parisienne hardtop
72 GMC Sierra

 

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 545
Date:

How about a hurst shifter with a GM handle like this....... http://canadianponcho.activeboard.com/forum.spark?aBID=118110&topicID=33813218&p=3



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 545
Date:

This is the bench seat one. If you have a bench seat....  https://www.impalaparts.com/product.php?productid=6467SHBH



__________________


Addicted!

Status: Offline
Posts: 339
Date:

ARCADIAN wrote:

Yes Carl you are correct. Islander I have the bench seat original style (repop) Muncie Shifter in my Chevelle, it works ok but is very sloppy and noisy. After reading up on the "new" Chinese Hurst shifters it was recommended to try and buy a "vintage" rebuilt one. I found one with a business called Manchester Muncies,the handle was rechromed & the mechanism completely rebuilt, shipped to me $310 U.S. I bought the correct install kit where I work for $210. I will install over the winter and should tighten things up. (I did like the vintage look with the original shifter though!)


 Arcadian, I remember asking you about the shifter that you installed in your Chevelle as this is the look I was going for, it sure looks right! Maybe you could post a picture for other members to see. I have had the opportunity to buy a few repro shifters but have been warned they are not that great. Same goes for the "new" Chinese Hurst models, although it might just be the stigma of offshore crap in our old North American vehicles!



__________________


Addicted!

Status: Offline
Posts: 339
Date:

Beaumont67SD wrote:

I have always preferred the look of the Hurst Comp Plus gray cast "T" handle over the original white Muncie ball.
- some period correct items, done in good taste...the Hurst handle just feels right, when laying down rubber
When I bought my '67 SD, I was glad it came with the Hurst shifter instead, while it did need a new bushing kit due to much wear.
- I have never looked for a factory correct one

Islander - got any pictures of you semi survivor 1966 Beaumont Custom...love to see it.


 



-- Edited by Beaumont67SD on Wednesday 24th of December 2014 07:41:12 AM


 I posted one pic here, http://canadianponcho.activeboard.com/t59183303/post-pictures-of-your-beaumont/?page=2  , from a year ago.



__________________


A Poncho Legend!

Status: Offline
Posts: 35601
Date:

IMG_0132.jpg



Attachments
__________________

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 611
Date:

Steve C wrote:

This is the bench seat one. If you have a bench seat....  https://www.impalaparts.com/product.php?productid=6467SHBH


I also bought the Muncie shift handle from www.impalaparts.com (but for a console) 

Works awesome with the Hurst Comp shifter!



__________________
"you can't burn out, if your not on fire" -Jim Morrison


Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 2656
Date:

Islander to see the bench seat shifter in My '65 Chevelle check out Bought a 1965 Chevelle 300 on this site and go to page 2 there are pictures of the interior showing the shifter.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 902
Date:

............my buddies 69 Impala SS had the factory muncie and it looked good and shifted great .   In my 67 Impala SS396  I put in the Hurst Competition Plus  and shifted it with the handle below which I kept after I sold the car.  It was a solid shifter, short stroke and worked excellent.    You know you could cheat alittle like I did on a friends 69 GTX one time.  Use the hurst linkage but weld on the factory style stick ,  the weld is hidden by the boot, so you have a stock look but the action of a Hurst. 

 

IM009308.JPG



Attachments
__________________


Addicted!

Status: Offline
Posts: 339
Date:

rabbit64cs wrote:

Comp + shifter all the way.. With the Muncie handle if you I want to look era correct. You'll possibly have to do some fabbing, to attach,  but that is all under the boot....

inland or Muncie shifter. Are just a little sloppy compared to the hurst.

if you buy used linkages, but the hurst pit pack with all new bushings and clips.. Tightens things up real nice.

 

i have a super comp hurst and handle in the 65 lemans..very positive shifting..I re bushed the linkages.

 

do you have a pic of what the original Muncie handle for 66 looks like?


 I don't have a pic close at hand, the general look is like the Impala, Chevelle, Chevy II or I should say Parisienne, Beaumont, Acadian from 1964-67(JohneeD posted a pic), round chrome stick with two ear reverse lockout. The stick attaches to the shifter body with two vertical studs and nuts. I have learned there is quite a variation in the sticks, 67 Beaumont/Chevelle for buckets/console has a different bend than 64-66. Bench seat for big car has a different bend than A body(Beaumont/Chevelle) and probably Acadian/Nova. Console cars came with a chrome ball with no pattern, as the shift pattern was on the console, bench seat cars in 64-67 came with a white ball with a black shift pattern inlay.

I had a complete bench seat shifter, it turned out for a B body, and the only parts that properly interchange with Beaumont are the shifter body and lever arms that bolt to the transmission and I didn't want to steal parts from it so I passed it on.

On a related issue, you could get a Saginaw in 67 and while the shifter body and stick are the same, the linkage is completely different, rare and not reproduced.....



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
.
Support Canadian Poncho!
Select Amount:
<
.
.
.