To me, i like the nostalga valve covers. It seem that the motor stands out more. With the black ones all i see is the intake, if you know what i mean. JMHO. They both look good,but like the nostalga look better.
I also like the nostalgia look. I found a set of the old finned aluminum Edelbrock valve covers that have been polished that I'm putting on my engine. James
i put a set of the classic finned eldebrock on the 283 in my 55 gmc, now i'm looking for someone to donate a pair for the 454 in my 63 because they aren't cheap. i've always liked the finned, but to each his own.
Just my $0.02 worth, but the nostalgia look is nicer for an older car. The new style covers look as though they belong on fuel injected engines. I have a set off of 95 Impala SS for free to anyone who wants to pay shipping.
They are now yours Carl. I will call home and see if I can get them shipped to you ASAP. I am away at work right now for another month or so but I will try to make it happen.
The tall aluminum valve covers go better with the way you have the engine setup. The black ones, look out of place. The black is one way to go to help dissipate heat. Semi flat black gives off heat better than polished/bright surfaces. But shiny, better.