Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: What if ??? Please post your opinion, I really want to hear what you think.
Should my Acadian have a Chevy or Pontiac engine [24 vote(s)]

Keep the 350 Chevy
54.2%
Install a 400 Pontiac
45.8%


Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 1057
Date:
What if ??? Please post your opinion, I really want to hear what you think.


Let me preface this topic with the fact that this will probably never happen, due to the expense involved.

For much of my adult life I hung around with a good friend that lived and breathed Pontiac's.  He had grown up a decade prior to me in the 50's and as a kid of the streets, he spent much of his time hanging out at the local gas station.  He progressed from washing cars to pumping gas and soon found he had a knack for working on cars primatily tuning motors.  In 1958 a customer bought a 58 Pontiac, I think this was a stripped down 2 door sedan and all I know about the motor is that it had a tri-power carb set-up in a quest to be king of the stop lights.  The owner soon became close friends with my buddy due to his ability to get the max performance out of that Pontiac. 
This friend of mine went on to work the counter of a local speed shop and soon found he was not destined to work for others.  He was rather out spoken and quick tempered.  I have heard of the term "short syndrone" and I think this fit my friend.  He was quick to fly into someone with fists flying in order to prove he was bigger and badder than his short & lightweight body appeared.  Eventually he owned and operated a combo repair and body shop in a building behind a motel that he bought as a means to keep his wife busy and out of his shop.  His 4 kids grew up detailing cars and the boys became excellent mechanics and bodymen.
We became friends in the 70's when most guys could not get along with him and he needed a companion to accompany him to the drag strip on weekends.  I was desperate to learn more about the cars I owned and the in's and out's of drag racing.  So even though I worked for Chevrolet all of my life and he was racing Pontiac's we formed a racing team and hit the road every weekend of the racing season.  This guy taught me everything about racing, drinking and how to sucessfully start a bar fight and then escape before the police came.
My friend passed away several years ago at the age of 65 but he really was gone prior to that.  All the years of drinking and smoking and doing pretty much everything to excess ruined his health from age 55 to his death.
His last full time race car is still owned by his sons, a 65 Gto coupe with his signature 400 ci motor and a variety of mismatched parts and suspension componets he had engineered and perfected.  He was not big on ordering a bunch of aftermarket parts from a catalog.  His 65 with the 400 motor, 400 turbo and a ten bolt rearend was capable of 9.60's on a good air day.

So now for the question.  In all of the time I spent with my friend, my 63 Acadian is now the first Pontiac I have owned in my 63 years.  The one thing that my friend was very out spoken about was what he fondly referred to as the "Bastard" Pontiac's at the track with Chevy engines.  I love my Acadian but I do somewhat feel I have disappointed my long time friend with my Pontiac/Chevy combo.
So somewhere in the back of my mind, there is a little voice that tells me, in tribute to my friend, I should right this wrong and build a 400 pontiac motor for my Acadian.
Now understand, this is not just a tribute but I really enjoy owning uniquely different cars.  I'm not sure how I would explain this because anyone with knowledge of the Acadian would expect to see a Chevy engine.  On the other hand some people would think it was original or at least a natural for the Candian Pontiac.
Question is, what do you guys think of the idea??  Is it sacreligious, just plain wrong or in some way is it the right thing to do??
Understand, my car is a long way from an original Acadian.  Lots and lots of modifications and pretty much a pro-touring car currently.

-- Edited by forespeed on Wednesday 23rd of December 2009 01:07:02 PM

-- Edited by forespeed on Wednesday 23rd of December 2009 01:10:57 PM

__________________

1951 Chevy Styleline -- Gasser

1966 Chevy Biscayne -- Sleeper

 



A Poncho Legend!

Status: Offline
Posts: 48941
Date:

I have been a die hard Pontiac'er since I was in my teens (2 now) but to me an Acadian would seem wrong with anything but a Chevy engine in it.

Not that I would scorn anyone who did it. Any engine in any body is true hot rodding, but I would most likely spend more time scoping out an Acadian at a show if it was big or small block powered than if it was Pontiac powered.

Bottom line is, it's your car. You have to be happy with what you build.

I ran a 427 in my Acadian for nearly 20 years. Now I wasn't happy with it and it's getting a 327 four speed because that makes ME happy.

__________________

1966 Strato Chief 2 door, 427 4 speed, 45,000 original miles 

1966 Grande Parisienne, 396 1 of 23 factory air cars (now converted to a "factory" 4 speed)



A Poncho Legend!

Status: Offline
Posts: 20075
Date:

The Chevy is what makes it uniquely Canadian. Nothing wrong with a good ole Poncho 400 though.

__________________

Ray White, Toronto ON

1973 LeMans 454 "Astro-Jet"

Built March 9, 1973 - Oshawa ON

1993 Corvette Convertible LT 1

Built January 10, 1993 - Bowling Green Kentucky 

 




Addicted!

Status: Offline
Posts: 175
Date:

It is your car and you can do what you like with it. It would really mess with people's heads at car shows, though.

Not an outrageous idea though.

ray

__________________

1970 Acadian SS350 4speed

1967 Chev C10 

White Rock, BC



Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 1057
Date:

My 2nd choice is a period correct motor, such as an L-79 clone or at least a 300 hp 327.  But that is not part of the poll just something I would probably do if I replace the 350 but stay with a Chevy.  There is just something about the 350, which is much more common in the 3rd gen Nova/Acadian cars.  My preference would be to switch to the more common 1st gen. sbc, 327ci.

-- Edited by forespeed on Wednesday 23rd of December 2009 01:26:09 PM

__________________

1951 Chevy Styleline -- Gasser

1966 Chevy Biscayne -- Sleeper

 



A Poncho Legend!

Status: Offline
Posts: 35601
Date:

We are seeing a time, where our American friends "might" start to see, the Canadian Chevy powered Pontiacs as Historically correct!  Witness the invitation to be a POCI chapter!  
  We all seem to bad mouth things, we don't know as truths... 
  Its a complicated question... 
We, as Canadians (conservative-laid back) would never no call a Acadian with a American Pontiac motor in it a Bastard (to your face) 
  These days, its seems to be a rather accepted thing, to do what each owners want!  lol (maybe its our age)  ...  With your contacts, I would rather see you do up a little Tempest or Lemans with the 400!   My news friends, here seem to accept the wierd ideas I have    Carl

__________________

 



Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 5682
Date:

Norm, as was said it's your car, do what YOU want, you can always save the parts & put it back to Chevy later on??? I don't see anything wrong with putting a big block Pontiac in it, after all it's is a PONTIAC  I'm still "toying" with the idea of doing the same with my 52 Canadian Torpedo back, making it all Pontiac even though it should be "Chebby" powered

__________________

Some times I wake up GRUMPY, but today I let her sleep in    !!!!!!!! BLACKSTOCK Ont.



Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8163
Date:

just look at the guy who has the buick 455 in his tubbed out 66 beaumont.Thats what hot rodding is all about build what you want,or what you got!My first vehicle was a 68 datsun p\u with a toyota moter in it what a piece of sh#t!

__________________

http://canadianponcho.activeboard.com/t51640378/timbuks-first-invader/ http://canadianponcho.activeboard.com/t63146560/timbuks-second-invader/  vancouver island



Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 2249
Date:

OK, my opinion:

1. Keep the SBC in the Acadain - it is part of what makes your Canadian Poncho unique, and since your car is a cruiser, you can get plenty of performance for modest sums of money and even get pretty good gas mileage, compard to any big block (lke a 400 Pontiac)

2. Buy an old poncho, maybe a 66 Tempest, that has a bad drive train, trashed interior, and needs full rebuild on suspension and brakes. Just a cheap, wornout, 2-door sedan. Build yourself a race car, stuffed with a 400 or a 455 or even bigger (hoiw about a 495? http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/PONTIAC-488-490-495-FORGED-STROKER-SHORT-BLOCK_W0QQcmdZViewItemQQhashZitem3350277153QQitemZ220388094291QQptZMotorsQ5fCarQ5fTruckQ5fPartsQ5fAccessories) Pontiac motor. Disc brake kit, new suspension bushings etc., find a 12-bolt rear end or even stick in a 9" Ford, gut the interior, a nice racing seat and full harness, roll cage, gut the dash and install your favorite brand of gauges in a sheet metal panel, body work as you see fit, and go see if you can come close to his 9 second runs.

Dave

__________________

56Pontiac  1956 Pontiac Pathfinder 2dr sedan, 496 - dyno'd 545 hp, stick shift, 4.11 posi - Hot Rod

  1964 Acadian Beaumont SD convert, 283 - factory 195 hp, Powerglide, 3.08 10-bolt - Cruiser

  2012 US-built crew cab truck - Daily Driver and Boat Trailering



Addicted!

Status: Offline
Posts: 405
Date:

Norm,just make your 350 look like a L/79 or GM Performance used to sell PONTIAC stamped valve covers. Just a thought.

__________________

chris newport



Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 2050
Date:

sd 455? It's going to be a race car pretty much, so go with your heart. If it's a tribute to your fallen friend, then do it and don't listen to what any one of us says.

__________________


Uber Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3932
Date:

I was going to do the same thing with my 69 Beaumont thats why my handle is Beaumont400 8. I had it mounted in the frame with little problems , A body headers fit. Then I found this site and my Canadian pride kicked  in and decided to go small block 350 maybe stroked to 383.  I still think it would be neat though. They make some great performance parts now for the pontiac engine.

__________________


Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 2530
Date:

I agree, real Canadianponcho cars like Acadian-Beaumont-Parisienne ... came with the Canadian Pontiac engines such as 283-327-350-427-454... and should house one of these motors. Some others like mine, built in Oshawa Ontario Canada or Ste-Therese Quebec Canada years 1971-79 came with the American Pontiac 350-400-455 and also the Canadian Pontiac engines, IMO what ever your car came with should go back in your engine bay.

__________________


Uber Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3813
Date:

I like thing the way they come from the factory but with that said I voted you change it out. If you want to do it as a tribute to a old friend who has past on go for it after all its you car do what makes you happy. You can always put the old drive train back if you so desire

__________________

1957 Pathfinder deluxe 4 door wagon
1961 Pontiac Parisienne bubble top Traded for a Harley sorry guys.

2007 Grand Prix Gxp

2009 Pontiac Montana SV6

Winnipeg MB 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 962
Date:

If your car is currently a pro touring car then you are free to do as YOU wish... Nobody looks for factory equipment in a pro touring car, besides the engine bay would look pretty full with that big old blue Pontiac in it. If you do it, then don't like it, you have everything there to put it back the way it was......my 2 cents

__________________

John

1972 Pontiac Lemans (daughter's car) 
2005 Pontiac Grand Am
2004 Ford Explorer Sport Trac



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 671
Date:

I stop carring what other people think along time ago just go with what feels right to you!

__________________

Im back new shop is kicking A$$

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 506
Date:

This is a interesting topic and hard choice. We as car lovers have likes and dis-likes but we are all gear heads . I love pontiac motors and am building one now but you have the car and do what you think would make you smile. If that smile comes from a high winding small block then cool. If the poncho motor gives you a good memory from a time past then thats maybe a direction to go. The bottom line is ,its a car, nuts and bolts and a driveline can be swapped out for a different day . Good luck

__________________

AAK

Dorchester Ont



A Poncho Legend!

Status: Offline
Posts: 26877
Date:

Do what ever makes you feel good!


__________________

Todd
Site Founder

Like us on Facebook. http://www.facebook.com/CanadianPoncho

Canadian Poncho World Headquarters - Prince Edward Island

 



Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 4767
Date:

my knee jerk reactions was "are you nuts".because of the issue of being so misunderstood as an acadian. but what ever floats your boat. its your car, pay the tribute. i'm sure he will be looking down and smiling.

__________________

sTevE

55 GMC, 70 Pontiac 2+2 rag



Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 2678
Date:

Norm I would bet you will lose some of the handling with the bigger motor. I would stay with sbc. My 2 cents.

__________________


Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 4519
Date:

You should do what you want with it; one suggestion: don't change it so much that it can't be put back to original, and keep whatever original parts you have. 

__________________

62 Catalina 2 dr post project

55 Bel Air 2 dr post 265PP/PG

68 Bel Air 2 dr post BB project

 



Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 1911
Date:

I think you should do what you think would be a fun project and you'd enjoy...for whatever your reasons... i do think that an sbc is the best motor for your car though, even lightened up a bit with some alum. heads... get a nice power to weight ratio working in your favour!

i'd like to see you take another acadian body like yours, put a straight axle in it, a 421 tri-power, 4 speed... three tall velocity stacks off the carbs out of the hood! even radius the wheel wells, some halibrand mag multi-spokes up front, chrome reverse and vintage slicks in the back... paint it your friends favourite colour, or multi colour, lacework etc.etc. and get a good artist with a brush to hand letter it as a tribute....ooooh, that sounds like a fun project!

ak

__________________

Wpg, MB

Numbers don't match! Especially HP and ET.  http://www.cardomain.com/ride/496943 



Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 6366
Date:

ak 67sd wrote:

I think you should do what you think would be a fun project and you'd enjoy...for whatever your reasons... i do think that an sbc is the best motor for your car though, even lightened up a bit with some alum. heads... get a nice power to weight ratio working in your favour!

i'd like to see you take another acadian body like yours, put a straight axle in it, a 421 tri-power, 4 speed... three tall velocity stacks off the carbs out of the hood! even radius the wheel wells, some halibrand mag multi-spokes up front, chrome reverse and vintage slicks in the back... paint it your friends favourite colour, or multi colour, lacework etc.etc. and get a good artist with a brush to hand letter it as a tribute....ooooh, that sounds like a fun project!

ak



Uh, Andrew-sounds like you have some serious taste ! never heard this side yet

 



__________________


Canadian Poncho Superstar!

Status: Offline
Posts: 6366
Date:

TINY wrote:

I stop carring what other people think along time ago just go with what feels right to you!




 what a great quality-low stress-



__________________


Poncho Master!

Status: Offline
Posts: 1131
Date:

stick with the sbc make it run in the 9s , keep it a canadian poncho, get a new car with a pontiac mill, way cooler, my buddy has a 540 bbc in a ford it flys but its still a turd, my 2 cents.

__________________
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
.
Support Canadian Poncho!
Select Amount:
<
.
.
.